HIST 207: History of the Climate Crisis
Emily Pawley
Introduction
While we may think of climate change mostly in terms of the futures it threatens, it’s a human-created disaster and so has a human history. So too do the solutions currently underway to respond to it. In this U.S.-focused class we’ll examine the rise of fossil fuels, the building of unequal and vulnerable landscapes, the birth and development of climate science, the intentional construction of climate denial, and the consequent failures of climate politics. However, we’ll also look at the histories of solutions like renewable energy, mass forest planting, ocean farming, protest, movement-building, regulation, and political action. In doing so, we’ll help create usable histories for a survivable and ethical future.
(Note from Emily: I am considering rewriting this whole thing with the U.S. decentered. Watch this space! If you want to know more more or make suggestions, send me a note!)
Note: As the course progresses I may tinker with it in response to our conversations. When there is a difference between the Brightspace page and this syllabus, always follow Brightspace.
Learning Objectives:
Goal 1: Students will develop a historical perspective that will help orient their thinking in terms of causes, consequences, and chronology, and will promote deeper understanding about and empathy for people who lived in other periods and places.
Goal 2: Students will learn research skills to help them locate essential historical information and will understand how to assess and categorize various types of primary and secondary sources.
Goal 3: Students will develop more effective writing and communication skills by learning how to formulate and support plausible historical interpretations.
Goal 4: Students will develop a framework understanding of the human causes of climate change, as well as the histories of climate science, climate denial, and climate solutions.
Goal 5: Students will develop the habit of develop the habit of connecting their learning about the past to positive change.
Readings
All readings will be available for download through Brightspace. In this course we will be working intensively with the arguments of professional historians. Learning to make sense of and critique these readings is a crucial intellectual skill. This will require kinds of reading skills that may differ from those you have used in your other classes. While we will be discussing these skills in class, you can also come talk to me about strategies and skills. You may also want to check out: http://blogs.swarthmore.edu/burke/permanent-features-advice-on-academia/how-to-read-in-college/
Participation and attendance policy
Energetic class participation is a crucial component both of the learning process and of the grade for this course. Please make every effort to attend all meetings of the class. In our first week, we will agree on criteria for good participation in class and I will abide by those criteria in assigning your grade.
You may be absent twice without penalty. (See the emergency policies below for further guidance). Of course you will be responsible for making up missed work and getting any notes you may need from your classmates
Class Reflection Journal: Throughout the course, both in and out of class, you will be asked to record your thoughts and responses to various prompts in a word document kept for the purpose. We’ll do this partly so I can get a sense of your thought patterns, but ultimately it is a tool for you, to help you develop a coherent intellectual response to the craft of history. We’ll also include a class timeline and a glossary for new terms. You may miss four entries without penalty.
Research Projects: This is a writing intensive course.
During the semester you will work on two research projects to give you a deeper understanding of climate history and a broader set of research skills. Every week after the beginning of each project, you’ll have a research task to do building toward the graded sections of these assignments. Some of these will be low-stakes writing and research assignments graded complete or incomplete. Others will be graded components.
In the first half of the semester, you will analyze and then contextualize an artifact of intentional climate denial in a series of short exercises. We’ll get most of our primary documents here from the internet archive Climate Files: http://www.climatefiles.com
In the second half of the semester, you’ll research and write a narrative history of a climate solution working backward from the solutions suggested by Project Drawdown https://drawdown.org/solutions
Week 1
Tue., Sept. 1: Introductory Conversation: What do we mean “History” of the Climate Crisis?
Fri., Sept 4: Climate Change Foundations Conversation: Joshua P. Howe, “This is Nature this is Un-Nature: Reading the Climate Curve” (2016)
Week 2: Causation: Beginnings of Climate Science and Climate Denial
Tue., Sept. 8: Spencer Weart, “The Idea of Anthropogenic Climate Change in the 20th Century,” and “The Discovery of Rapid Climate Change”
Fri., Sept. 10: Naomi Oreskes and Eric Conway, “Challenging Knowledge: How Climate Science became a Victim of the Cold War,” 2008.
Climate Denial Project Assigned
Week 3: Causation Climate Policy Continued / Debating the Anthropocene
Tue., Sept. 15: James Morton Turner and Drew Isenberg, “American Exceptionalism in a Warming World” (see deliverable notes about what you’re going to read!!) from The Republican Reversal, 2018 —Note—I do this as a jigsaw style class, where I break the class into groups and they’re each responsible for explaining the policies of a different presidential administration.
Climate Denial Document Choice Due
Fri., Sept. 18 Document annotation day!
Document Annotation Due
Week 4: Causation: Fossil Fuel Stories
Tue., Sept. 22: David Nye, “The High Energy Society”
Fri., Sept. 25: Christoph Bonneuil and Jean-Baptiste Fressoz, Thanatocene” from The Shock of the Anthropocene (2016)
Document Sketch Due
Week 5: Causation: Consumption and Denial
Tues. Sept. 29: Lizabeth Cohen, “Culture: Segmenting the Mass” from A Consumers’ Republic, 2003.
Fri., Oct. 2: Riley E. Dunlap and Aaron M. McCright, “Organized Climate Change Denial” from The Oxford Handbook of Climate Change and Society, 2011.
In Class: Newspaper Primary Sources Practice
Week 6: Complicating Causation: Hurricanes and Coloniality
Tue., Oct. 6: Ted Steinberg, excerpts, Acts of God
Fri., Oct. 9: Gustavo A. Garcia-López, “The Multiple Layers of Environmental Injustice in Contexts of (Un)natural Disasters: The Case of Puerto Rico Post-Hurricane Maria” (2018)
Climate Denial Documents: Sources and Annotations Due
Week 7: Writing Process Week
Tue., Oct 11: Peer Review Draft of Climate Denial Document Reports:
Fri., Oct. 14: Open Work Session and Trouble Shooting
Climate Denial Document Reports Due At Midnight.
Week 8: Pivoting!
Tue., Oct. 20: NO CLASS FALL PAUSE
Fri., Oct. 23: Beginning the Solutions Project—Using Project Drawdown—see Brightspace for instructions.
Solutions Project Assigned
Week 9: Climate Action Histories: Bottom Up Stories
Tue., Oct. 27: Excerpt from What if we Get it Right
EVENING TALK BY AYANA ELIZABETH JOHNSON 7 PM ATS
Solutions Choice Due
Fri., Oct. 30: Excerpts from Nick Estes, “Our History is the Future;” Dallas Goldtooth et. al “Indigenous Resistance to Carbon”
Week 10: Climate Action Histories 2: Top Down Stories
Tue., Nov. 3: Election Day Research Workshop
Solution History Basic Sketch Due
Fri., Nov. 6: Research Skills Workshop
Week 11: Histories of Planned Futures
Tue., Nov. 10: David Vogel, “California’s Environmental Policy Leadership”
Key Source Exploratory Essay Due
Fri., Nov. 13: “Capturing” from Holly Jean Buck, After Geoengineering, (2019)
Week 12: Restoration
Tue., Nov. 17: Student Meetings with Professor Pawley
Outline with Evidence Due
Fri., Nov. 20: Elizabeth Kolbert, “The Darkening Ocean,”; Excerpts Irus Braverman, The Coral Whisperers, (2018).
Week 13: Restoration Histories
Tue., Nov. 24:
Writing Workshop
Heart of Paper Due
Thanksgiving! No Friday Class!
Week 14: Writing and Avoiding Despair
Tue., Dec. 1: Pawley, “Despair as Analytical Failure”
Fri., Dec. 4: Presentation Workshop—peer review
Draft of presentation script due
Week 15: Hearing from Each Other
Tue., Dec. 8: Presenting the Heart of the Project, Group 1
Presentation!—Submit Powerpoint and notes to Prof. Pawley
Fri., Dec. 11: Presenting the Heart of the Project group 2 and reflections
Presentation!—Submit Powerpoint and notes to Prof. P.
Final Exam Period
Sat., Dec 19
Final Paper due on Brightspace