LESSON PLAN: Conference of Parties + Politics of Global Climate (In)Justice Simulation
Undergraduate level
Designed by Paul Nauert, adapted from materials developed by Mikael Wolfe in 2019
All lesson materials included in the toolkit are published under the terms of the Creative Commons license: CC BY-NC-SA 4.0. This means you can freely use and remix the materials as long as you attribute the source and release any versions you remix under the same license, which includes not commercializing any of the materials.
Learning goal: Explore the ethical role of governments in addressing climate change on a global scale by simulating part of the international conversation and coordination at a COP meeting.
Each group represents a different society or perspective participating in the global politics of climate (in)justice and coordinating climate action.
Handout
Context: It is late 2019. World leaders have assembled in Chile for the 25th annual COP meeting. The stakes are higher than ever for the global community. Last year, the IPCC report warned that carbon emissions must be cut by 45% from 2010 levels by 2030 and reach zero by 2050 to avoid tipping into climate catastrophe (i.e. keeping global temperature from increasing more than 1.5 degree Celsius). Evidence continues to mount in the scientific scholarship and current events (e.g. faster than expected melting of Greenland ice in the past year) pointing to the magnitude of the crisis.
At the last COP meeting in Poland, nations agreed on some elements of the 2015 Paris Agreement rulebook (i.e. the framework for how governments will assess and hold each other accountable to their climate action goals). However, major questions were left unresolved, including key specifics on how: to expand nationally determined contributions (NDCs) to reducing emissions; fund transition to non-carbon fuels in developing nations, mechanisms for how to count and economically quantify carbon offsets in global markets, particularly forests and air travel, and whether China should be held to the same standards as the EU and U.S. in emission reduction goals.
Meanwhile, activists around the world (from supporters of a Green New Deal in the U.S. to Indigenous community members in the circumpolar region) have criticized the outcomes of the meeting as insufficient and urged more urgent, forceful action. On the other hand, some nations (especially those with large carbon industries like the U.S., Russia, and Saudi Arabia) and the fossil fuel industry have argued for more modest action (or complete inaction).
Goals: The meeting this year (2019) has set a goal of resolving questions from the 2018 COP and clearly reasserting the goals and values driving the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) as COP reaches a quarter-century of existence. The work this year will set the stage for success - or failure - at the all-important COP in 2020 when countries present their progress toward climate goals and make final decisions on committing to more rigorous goals for the 2020s.
Formulate your positions on the following key question from the perspective of your group’s subject-position. Prepare to present your replies in 2-3 minutes max by your group’s spokesperson. After hearing each group’s response, you will reconvene to discuss your response. Your goal as a global community is to reach consensus on a common vision and set of goals. Your goal as a small group is to represent your subject position. You will need to balance these in simulated negotiations with other groups (see below for list of groups). In your responses and negotiations, cite from course materials wherever possible.
Remember: Be passionate and creative in your responses. Be in character!
Questions — your group facilitator should ensure that every group member has a chance to speak. Your spokesperson should then present your replies concisely to the big group:
What are your proposed target years and emissions levels for global climate action? (e.g. X% reduction in carbon by what year?) Do you find the IPCC Report recommendation (see above) too aggressive, not aggressive enough, or just right?
What do you propose as the main strategies for transitioning off carbon / keeping global temperature rise below 1.5 degrees at a global level?
Who in the global community should pay for the transition to a decarbonized economy? Which specific countries or groups of countries represented in the room?
How should nations breaking commitments be held accountable?
Given your proposed global goals, what specific actions will the country/region your group represents take toward this goal?
Given your proposed global goals, what are your specific demands of other groups?
List of nations/regions represented by groups in the room today (see group descriptions below):
The U.S. (national government, led by the Trump administration)
Subnational groups within the U.S. that have broken with the U.S. national government to support the 2015 Paris Agreement goals (e.g. 10 states, 280 cities and counties, and thousands of other NGOs and companies, according to the We’re Still In Pledge, amounting to nearly 50% of U.S. emissions)
The European Union (EU)
China
India
The Maldives
Costa Rica
Angola
Global delegation of young people visiting from 2119
Non-human nature (e.g. animals, glaciers, forests, coral reefs)
Sources for data in handout: IPCC 2018 Report, We Are Still In - Signatories Page, International Monetary Fund and the World Bank (economic data), International Energy Agency, European Commission (CO2 emissions), Carbon Brief, The Guardian, The Conversation, and the United Nations news agency, Climate Action Tracker, Climate Links (for COP details and country-level policy details)
Lesson plan:
Timeline
10 minutes - explain activity (goals, where we stand as COP 25 begins), break into groups
15 minutes - small group discussion
30 minutes - small group proposals [while students speak through these, I will capture notes in real-time in the below table projected on the main screen so they have a reference point for negotiations and to simulate the complexity of these negotiations.]
5 minutes - small group discussion of other groups' proposals + follow up questions from me (e.g. scientists, activists, fossil fuel)
10 minutes - negotiations; work to align
5 minutes - regroup in small groups to discuss responses and adjust positions
5 minutes - final positions stated; see where we land -- the Santiago Declaration
10 minutes - debrief
Table to capture each group’s reply
Questions for midpoint:
Massive protests in the streets outside and activists drop a banner in the conference hall accusing governments of acting too slowly - how do you respond?
(If needed) - push non-rich nations to demand more of rich nations and push rich nations to respond
World stock markets crashed in the week's before COP and many economists are forecasting a major multi-year economic downturn with governments facing reduced tax revenues. Unemployment is rising globally and food prices are rising in poorer nations. How does this change the stakes?
Questions for debrief:
(If groups align easily) - why not this alignment in real life?
What did this teach us about the role of governments in addressing climate change?
What does this teach us about how international conversation and coordination works on climate change
What makes an actual cop more or less difficult?
What groups were not represented here?
What did you think of the bounds of the discussion (i.e. questions asked) -- should other questions be considered (e.g. historical reparations, geoengineering, etc.)?
How could non-human nature or future generations be part of COP in real life?
Where do scientists, activists, or corporations fit into this?
How would the denialists respond to all of this?
Group descriptions:
United States National Government: Your group represents the United States national government. Led by President Trump, the U.S. pulled out of the Paris Agreement in 2017 and, along with other nations with major fossil fuel industries (e.g. Russia, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait) argued for less urgent language and more modest action (or inaction) at the last COP. Your nation/region has per-capita carbon emissions of 15.53 tons. Historically, you have contributed about 26% to total global emissions and today make up 15% of total emissions. Your nation/region’s GDP is about $19T and makes up 24.3% of the global economy.
United States Subnational Groups: Your group represents a coalition of subnational groups within the U.S. that have broken with the U.S. national government to support the 2015 Paris Agreement goals (to date, 10 states, 280 cities and counties, and thousands of other NGOs and companies, according to the We’re Still In Pledge, amounting to nearly 50% of U.S. emissions). You have taken a clear stand against the current U.S. national government’s stance on climate inaction. However, much of your action must be coordinated across complex layers of state and city government and depends on voluntary actions of civil society and corporate groups.
The European Union (EU): Your group represents the European Union’s regional government. While issues like Brexit have called the future of the EU into question and Yellow Vest protests in France have highlighted popular discontent with fuel taxes (without a supporting framework for a just transition out of a carbon economy), many of your member states have forged ahead on climate action in recent years. In early 2019, for example, Germany announced the planned shutdown of all its coal power plants by 2038. At the 2018 COP, the EU, UK, France, and Germany (along with Argentina, Mexico, and Canada) have pledged to increase climate action goals in 2020. Along with China, you have increasingly stepped into a global leadership role produced by U.S. withdrawal from the Paris Agreement. Yet, you disagree with China on key points, arguing that China should be held to the same emission reductions standards as the EU. The EU has per-capita carbon emissions of 6.375 tons. Historically, major economies in Western Europe have contributed about 11.4% to 27.8% to total global emissions and today make up 9.6% of total emissions. Your nation/region’s GDP is about $17.9T and makes up 16.53% of the global economy.
China: Your group represents China. Over the past thirty years, your economy and role on the global stage has grown extraordinarily. Your economy leads the world in coal consumption and solar power technology manufacturing. Along with the EU, you have increasingly taken on a leading role in international climate diplomacy after the U.S. pulled out of the Paris Agreement in 2017, including actively urging other nations to stay committed to the agreement. Policymakers have included systematic discussion of climate action in your national Five-Year development plans. You are on track to meet your National Determined Contribution, but critics globally have charged the goal as far short of what is required given the size of your economy. Your nation/region has per-capita carbon emissions of 6.59. Historically, you have contributed about 10% to total global emissions and today make up 28% of total emissions. Your nation/region’s GDP is about $12T and makes up 14.8% of the global economy.
India: Your group represents India. A major player in global climate diplomacy as a key voice of the global South, you historically have argued strongly for holding developing nations to a different standard than developed nations (i.e. reduced emission reductions) on the principle of historical equity (i.e. wealthy nations grew rich with limits on emissions, so developing nations should be given a chance to grow economically while rich nations shoulder more of the costs of a global transition to a non-carbon economy). At the last COP, however, you signaled a willingness to increase your own national climate pledge. Meanwhile, within India, your policymakers have placed you on track to Nationally Determined Contribution goals, yet significant uncertainty remains about the future of coal power in India and emissions from a growing middle class (e.g. more air travel consumption). Your nation/region has per-capita carbon emissions of 1.58 tons. Historically, you have contributed about 3% to total global emissions and today make up 6% of total emissions. Your nation/region’s GDP is about $2.6T and makes up 2.83% of the global economy.
Angola: Your group represents Angola. Located in southwestern Africa with a population of about 25 million, your nation has rich mineral and precious metal deposits as well as great biodiversity, yet has struggled economically with the catastrophic consequences of a long history of colonialism and civil war. Researchers estimate that climate change will exacerbate already decreasing access to clean water, negatively impact agriculture and fishing yields, and increase the potential of diseases like malaria and yellow fever due to more extreme rain events. Your nation/region has per-capita carbon emissions of 1.29 tons (roughly the equivalent of two round-trip flights from San Francisco to New York City). Historically and today, you have contributed negligible amounts to overall carbon emissions. Your nation/region’s GDP is about $198.8B, a very small fraction of the world economy.
Global delegation of young people visiting from 2119: You are a global delegation of young people visiting from the year 2119. You have time-traveled back a century to the COP 2019 meeting for one day to deliver your advice to everyone gathered here on what action to take and how in the remaining decades of the twenty-first century. Since you are not representing a single country or region, but rather future humanity, think creatively about your responses to each question and speak with passion about what you have seen in the early twenty-second century.
Non-human nature: You represent non-human nature (any and all non-human systems, living or non-living - e.g. endangered animal species, glaciers, rivers, tundra, forests, coral reefs, the atmosphere). You have been given an opportunity to address the humans assembled at the COP 2019 meeting to deliver your advice to everyone gathered here on what action to take and how in the remaining decades of the twenty-first century. Since you are not representing a single country or region, but rather global non-human nature, think creatively about your responses to each question confronting humanity and speak with passion about what you see as the consequences of human choices for non-humans.